|
|
Welcome to the Exploding Garrmondo Weiner Interactive Swiss Army Penis. |
GFF is a community of gaming and music enthusiasts. We have a team of dedicated moderators, constant member-organized activities, and plenty of custom features, including our unique journal system. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ or our GFWiki. You will have to register before you can post. Membership is completely free (and gets rid of the pesky advertisement unit underneath this message).
|
|
Thread Tools |
Illegal Downloads aka the Hong Kong of the Internet
We seem to do this in mass on GFF, so I made a thread about the whole issue. Do you illegally download (which would probably reveal what you think about the issue)? Is it on the rise or decline? What is most downloaded?
Enough with the questions, consider this a all inlcusive discussion on the topic; put news, opinion and whatever else you think about the topic here. I personally download illegaly, quite a bit in fact. Though I have tried to wean myself off the illegal programs with freeware and OSS software, it hasn't been completed yet; in fact I have never paid for software that wasn't a game. I think downloading whatever you please is not morally wrong, the whole debate was caused by overactive intellectual property holders. Someone most likely paid for the item in question down the line and decided to share it and spare the people the expense of paying for the item. In >99% of the cases, I would have never considered buying or even trying the software/media, in fact the commercial programs that I have tried have encouraged me to use more freeware software. I wouldn't even use Windows if it wasn't for the fact that most of the software I use (namely older games) wouldn't work on Linux. Though the RIAA and MPAA seem to state that file sharing is on the decline (meaning they're winning the war), I, in fact think it's far more common and easier than it ever was. Google makes it far too easy to find a direct link (or torrent) to the file, it's like we all live in Hong Kong and can find whatever we like if we go down the right street. What is download and why we download is a question that peers into the logic of almost every internet user, broadband wouldn't be as near as successful if it was only used for gaming and faster page loading. Really, until recently you couldn't even acquire motion pictures online, most of the larger (meaning around 700MB and higher) items you can aquire online are shared games, CDs, DVDs and operating systems. It seems though that the RIAA and MPAA are blindly prosecuting the wrong targets, those who download most are going undectected while numerous people who don't or can't download get the shaft by the RIAA. Scare tactics will never work, until they monitor the source and destination of all the internet traffic (and act on that information), they'll never see any reduction of downloads. Right now only two programs I'm using are not "licensed", Windows XP Professional and Diskeeper 10 Server Enterprise. Otherwise all my other stuff currently active is legal, all my other shady stuff is dormant at the moment. They'll have to learn, free is an unbeatable price. If you can get it easily for free, you'll get customers in large amounts. The fact that none of this stuff requires a physical presense in any stage of the transfer makes downloading so popular. Jam it back in, in the dark. |
I'm still in high school, live at home, and have about 1000 downloaded albums, about 30% of which are out-of-print. 100% of the money I get goes towards buying records, so I feel no guilt whatsoever downloading music. I would buy it if I had the money, and I probably will buy it eventually.
There's nowhere I can't reach. |
A lot of the programs which I have downloaded are not stuff even remotely within my possible budget(SolidWorks, ProE, Reason 3.0, Cakewalk Dimension, etc). If I did not download them, I would most likely never buy them.
Most of the games I download I eventually buy after trying them out. As for music, I have a considerable collection, but a lot of it is relatively hard to find stuff that gets passed around in the Concert Hall. Because it is not mainstream music, it is more expensive. I try to keep my eyes open for good deals on these rare finds for purchase, as I like to have original CDs, but this doesn't happen too often. I apply this same reasoning to a lot of the anime and manga that I download. These are the justifications I give for doing what I do in regards to downloading. This thing is sticky, and I don't like it. I don't appreciate it. |
Downloading music has always made me feel bad.
I think it's wrong to download music because it takes money away from the people who made it. I especially feel bad when I'm downloading music that was made by an unpopular or less than rich artist. It makes me feel like I'm killing off their career because I'm not actually giving them money to fund their career. I say this but look at me now. I'm on a VGM site where I constantly download VGM music. Not to mention, go on Direct Connect and have a field day. Just call me Hippo because I'm a hypocrite. The only time I do (the don't was a mistake eariler) feel okay about people downloading and sharing music is when it's a rare soundtrack that nobody can just go and buy. When there actually isn't an option to buy it anymore. How ya doing, buddy?
Last edited by vuigun; Apr 25, 2006 at 09:55 PM.
|
The RIAA is an illegal price fixing cartel that shouldn't even exist under US law. They use intimidation and other scare tactics to settle out of court where they know they wouldn't win because they gather info on downloaders by illegal means, and most often they turn out to be people who HAVEN'T done anything. Do I feel guilty about stealing money from them? I think I'd feel guilty if I started letting them steal MY money.
I was speaking idiomatically. |
I download mostly everything.
Applications/Software - I've only ever bought a couple software titles. Every other time I download it becuase it's usually way out of my price range. Adobe Illustrator CS2? Yeah right, I'm still in highschool. Movies - Same deal. Seeing as an anime dvd (which only contains about 4 sessions) is priced at about $30, it would cost me about 200$ for a season of anime... no thanks. Music - I download all my music. First of all, it is perfectly legal (I live in Canada), and it's conveniant. A lot of the music I listen to is foreign (Japanese), and obtaining the legitimate redbook-CDs is difficult. When I can, I buy an album that I really like, becase I think that the artist has deserved my money. While I understand that downloading illegaly is "wrong" and illegal, I justify it thusly: I am aware of what is available to me, and I have limited funds. If I want to use a program/listen to music/watch a movie, and am perfectly able to, I'm not going to let the issue of legality get in the way. "I want to listen to "X" artist, and can do so in about 10 minutes, as soon as I download the album. Great... too bad It's "wrong"." As far as I'm concerned, I'm going to listen to the damn music. What kind of toxic man-thing is happening now? Mario Kart DS: 498293-921939____ Star Fox Command: 155-576-696-451____ Metroid Prime Hunters: 4854-1233-4943____ Final Fantasy III: 506891214495____ Xfire: freuser____ Steam: Free.User____ |
My main problem with downloading music is that I think "Is the artist I love going to be able to make a new album if I'm not funding their career". When I think if that, it makes me not want to download music....but I still do anyway. Yep...soniclover the hypocrite. FELIPE NO
Last edited by vuigun; Apr 25, 2006 at 07:13 PM.
|
What, you don't want my bikini-clad body? |
Well, yes, you do have a point there. I guess my post was more implied to an artist's music in the region you are living in.
I guess if it's music from a different region then it's doesn't effect the artist as much. Jam it back in, in the dark. |
There's nowhere I can't reach. Mario Kart DS: 498293-921939____ Star Fox Command: 155-576-696-451____ Metroid Prime Hunters: 4854-1233-4943____ Final Fantasy III: 506891214495____ Xfire: freuser____ Steam: Free.User____ |
I used to use a lot of pirate software when I was younger, and now don't use any. I still get some songs which I'm not entitled to, but buy albums and songs as well. I often download things, evaluate them, and decide whether or not I want to buy that artist's stuff. Same goes for movies. I'll download movies that aren't available to rent (or sometimes just because I want to), but being a stickler for quality transfers and a sucker for commentaries, I buy the DVDs of the movies I like.
How ya doing, buddy?
"The avalanche has already started. It is too late for the pebbles to vote."
|
How ya doing, buddy? |
Um...
My whole debate on this is.... You can now get High Speed Internet where you can connect to the internet (thus download) at speeds so insane (i personally have a 2.2g speed) so i can download at on average, 100kbps. What other purpose would ISP's give out so much speed, if it wasnt to download/upload....would you really need it that fast to send a document from the UK to the US for example...? Highly unlikey is the most respected answer! If it was really that easy for the RIAA to obtain info on who downloads from where, who and waht, we would be fucked over a barrel by now...i have been downloading music and other variable formats for best part of 8 years... Now i am either downloading stuff that the RIAA are not concerned about, which i highly doubt....Or it is because the RIAA are nothing but oversensuos idiots that go out of their merry way of life to try and gain money the easy way, as Darklink pointed out.... Scare tactics have never stopped me from doing what i do....And i have to point out at this point that i do buy Music and DVD's still that would keep the business ticking over, so for me...am i guilty for downloading the stuff i do....Like F*** am i.... As i have said, i have done it now for 8 years or so, and im sure i will be doing it for the next 8 or more.... Lets face the bare facts here.... You can purchase CD Burners, DVD Burners....CD's to burn data and such on...DVD's to burn data and such on Stupid sized HD's (i think 10gig HD would suffice the norm)...And that also spreads to equipment you can get for home use as well as PC use.....So come people (and the RIAA) if it was "Illegal" to download music and burn music and other data to CD...I think you should be starting with those outlets that sell the above stuff that clearly encourages people like us to do it....Cos for me anyway....If i didnt have a DVD Burner, DVD's to burn on... I guess i wouldnt be able to burn music ...And if i didnt have an exceptional sized HD (more than 1 actually) i guess i wouldnt be able to store msuci and other medias as i do.... So who really is to blame overall? us for downloading the media....or the stores for making it more accetable bu supplying equipment that enables to store more and download more..Faster and to burn stuff for our own pleasure & Others?????? I was speaking idiomatically. |
Blaming this on retail chains that sell equipment which facilitates illegal downloading is much like placing the blame for the 9/11 attacks on Boeing. Just because something can be used for an illegal purpose doesn't make the thing itself illegal. Blaming companies who sell computer equipment is simply asinine.
If an album can't even be bought anymore, downloading isn't so much of an issue, as, again, there is no way to legally obtain the album. What kind of toxic man-thing is happening now?
Last edited by Snowknight; Apr 25, 2006 at 09:52 PM.
|
(Please tell me I didn't make that Mistake.)
Um guys, I meant to put doinstead of that don't in my post about downloading rare albums. :doh: Sorry for the confusion but hey...mistakes happen. :juggler: I'll go edit it now. FELIPE NO |
On the note of ill-begoten software, Microsoft has released a new WGA program, it will check your Windows install for authenticity and will spam you if it's illegal. The workaround is to disiable automatic updating and do a manual update. Just uncheck any WGA tools listed in the High Priority Updates (I even told Windows Update to not list it), and you'll be home free, for now. Like I've said before if most of the programs I use required Windows, I'd be using something else right now. Of course when has nagging ever got people to stop using Windows without a vaild key?
What, you don't want my bikini-clad body?
Last edited by Kaiten; Apr 26, 2006 at 06:02 PM.
|
Jam it back in, in the dark. |
It'll be in the High Priority Update list in the Custom Update list. But if you have Automatic Updates enabled (as the Windows bitches to you if you don't have it on), you might already have it installed. I'll Supply you with a screenshot soon.
There's nowhere I can't reach. |
This thing is sticky, and I don't like it. I don't appreciate it. Mario Kart DS: 498293-921939____ Star Fox Command: 155-576-696-451____ Metroid Prime Hunters: 4854-1233-4943____ Final Fantasy III: 506891214495____ Xfire: freuser____ Steam: Free.User____
Last edited by Free.User; Apr 25, 2006 at 10:55 PM.
|
Do I download? Yes. Is most of the stuff I download illegal to? In general, no. Most of my commonly-available music collection I actually legally own, be it in LP, Cassette, or CD (no 8-Tracks, however). When I download it's either Symphonic Stuff, Wind Ensemble stuff (good luck finding CDs of that), or VGM (not available in America). And the stuff of that that I truly love I often will import to get it legally (example: I have 3 albums by the Tokyo Kosei Wind Symphony - stunning group, I'd buy their entire discography except that it's like 200 albums and they're all $20 apiece to import from Japan)
On the topic itself: Is it illegal to download (copyrighted) music? Of course. Should it be illegal? Of course. Does it help the economy? In my opinion yes. Examples of artists that I first heard through downloading and have ended up buying: Lifehouse, Tokyo Kosei Wind Symphony, Dave Matthews Band, and every piece of VGM I own (that's just a start; there are more as well). Piracy gets music spread around, which in the end is beneficial to the artist. I am a dolphin, do you want me on your body? |
Downloading mp3's is just like tape trading. And god knows how many now legendary artists got their start through that. If the artist is serious, people hearing the music is what matters to them anyway.
Most amazing jew boots |
Then they're not going to be too happy What kind of toxic man-thing is happening now? |
FELIPE NO |
It was cracked already, too unless they've put out another new version in the last couple days. Windows.Genuine.Advantage.Validation.v1.5.526.0.CR ACKED-ETH0 What, you don't want my bikini-clad body? |
I don't feel too guilty downloading movies, I watch them in the theater anyway because I like the effect you get there, and I will buy the DVD anyway for the extra features. I then delete the movie from my computer.
Jam it back in, in the dark. |