Any interest in a 'Top Songs of All Time' project dealie?

Look, if you put the call out for a list, I will oblige. But a couple things:

1. I think it would work best if the discussed BSC Off-Season Clash doesn't come through as expected.

2. It needs to have some other element to it -- a countdown with links to downloadable songs or albums, or (better yet) a daily posting of a track where we can comment and scrutinize and so forth.

Also ...

Originally Posted by Elorin

But to actually rank all 300 songs is a bit much. That said, I think a top 10, 15 or 20 ranked list is still manageable for me.

When magazines, web sites etc. put together these massive fan voted lists, they ask for people's Top 5 or 10 choices, and then make the list from there. It's easier for participants that way. Point being, you would need a lot of participants to make it work, probably from multiple other sites.

If you can pull it off, great, happy to partake.

Jam it back in, in the dark.

Okay, let me rephrase: I'm not opposed to the idea of large lists. In fact, for me it will be fun. I'm just worried it may be a barrier to entry for some. On the other hand, I think it will impossible to get the necessary number of participants (read: in the hundreds) to make small lists work. Large lists may be the only way to go.

There's nowhere I can't reach.