|
Also, a pretty nice score from Mark Morgan, which makes one wonder where he disappeared to.
|
He had to pull out of his next score (Giants:Citizen Kabuto) due to illness or some other kind of serious problem; I'm guessing this has kept him sidelined.
|
I'm saying it's an irony to see that the makers of Planescape (if only one of them) would credit FFVII and VIII (I notice that you didn't touch that one, heh heh) with influencing them when I've seen a lot of CRPG fans condemn those two JRPGs.
|
You're totally right. Frankly, I think that a lot of CRPGers are critiquing the fanbase more than the game itself, which is perfectly valid. Planescape has often felt to me like a great fusion of western (stat-based, nonlinear) and eastern (story-based, linear) RPG traditions.
|
As for the literary quality thing...I'm just going to say that the content of the dialog matters more to me than its volume. Not that I don't understand the correlation you're making. Another problem is that I'm not a 'story conquers all' kind of RPGer. I've always been more of a gameplay guy. Therefore a great story alone is not enough for me to place an RPG among the cream of the crop. Good game design is very important to me.
|
I can appreciate that. I myself am a 'story conquers all' RPGer, which tends to color my perceptions. As for the million words, I just think it's a particularly impressive figure. I agree that quantity of verbage does not quality make; just look at Xenosaga.
There's nowhere I can't reach.