[PC] Super Mario MUGEN

Originally Posted by Soluzar

I'm a bit dissapointed that the overworld map looks more like SMB3 than SMW because I must be the only person ever who doesn't really like SMB3 the best. That said, this game is probably still going to be awesome. If they ever finish it.

I much prefer SMW over SMB3 in every way, but my main issue is with the use of Super Mario All-Stars sprites, which I was never that fond of. I would have much rather seen either NES sprites or Mario World stuff.

Jam it back in, in the dark.

Originally Posted by Chaotic

With the latest update, if they had used the NES sprites, I don't think they would've blended as well with all the other sprites used in the game. In a way, it would've seemed like they half-assed it along the way using the lesser quality sprites.

I have nothing against the NES sprites, but overall with game design the All-Star sprites just made more sense.

You're making my head hurt with this circle conclusion.
There's a Game Boy Wario sprite and a Mega Man 2 level, not to mention ROUNDED Sonic 3 style Sonic sprites; how does using Mario All-Stars sprites make any more or less "sense" than using NES era Mario sprites (and I'm not just talking for playable characters)? It's not as if there haven't been Mario sprites after Mario All-Stars, much less far prettier and/or detailed ones before or since.

Ok, so the guy really, really likes SMB3, so he themes practically the whole game around it, both structure and interface. I'm saying it was a silly idea to go with the All-Stars version as it is not a very pretty example of 16-bit graphics. This subjective view is not explained away by going "well it's all based on All-Stars, so it makes sense"

There's nowhere I can't reach.