[SotW] Song of the Week - WEEK 115 Voting/WEEK 116 Nominating

3 points: Kukeiha Club pro-fusion ~Salamander~ - SENSATION
2 points: The Lunatic - Ibara Remix Tracks - Endress Train
1 point: Sephiroth - Oriental Memory of Forgathering Dream ~phantasmagoria~
Close: Sega Tunes - ToeJam & Earl in Panic on Funkotron - Mellow Groove

Additional Spam:

Originally Posted by CHz

We've already had a doujin arrangement by ZTS place, "if it dies rather -short.rm-" in week 109. So, recalling that, I didn't have a problem with the current track from Sephiroth (which is a Touhou arrange album, not a game) when it was nominated last week.

However, I decided to look into it anyway now just to be certain, and it appears that I wasn't particularly diligent about checking up on him the first time. I can only find three composition credits: Parhelia (half the soundtrack, or 8 tracks), Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (4 tracks), and DJMAX Portable 2 (2 tracks). Everything else he's done, and there is quite a bit that he's done, is either a fan or official arrangement (pretty much all fan, but I did see an arrangement on the Glove On Fight OST).

so yeah um right

Well, I mean, if I'm understanding this correctly, he's had pro credits as a composer. So what was the problem? Not enough credits to be considered a focused VGM composer? Not that I make the rules, and this obviously goes case-by-case: If the nom isn't mainstream stuff, the guy has even 1 legit composer credit, and he's most known for VGM (even if it's mostly doujin/official arrangements), then what's the problem? As soon as a guy gets a pro credit and they're dedicated to VGM, they seem fine to me.

Most amazing jew boots

He mocks you!

There's nowhere I can't reach.

3, go. :-)

This thing is sticky, and I don't like it. I don't appreciate it.