|
New Fullmetal Alchemist anime series
They are doing it by the book this time :)
Fullmetal Alchemist: New Series, Confirmed It is not a continuation of the previous anime, as that ended pretty definitively with Ed and Al being separated in different worlds, but instead they are going back and making it true to the manga. I'm rather excited for this as I loved the first anime series, but it means that now I'm going to have to go back and read the manga again. I didn't get far in it to begin with as I only read the volumes that my school library had. I at least got far enough to know that the manga and anime are completely different, so this should be interesting :) The teaser for it: Spoiler:
|
Can't wait for this new one. But didn't the manga come after the anime..??
|
Quote:
|
I wonder how they'll animate the things that were identical between the original anime and the manga. I thought some of the early episodes were fairly well done.
|
That's cool. I enjoyed the TV series, so I'll be looking forward to this.
|
In other news, The original seiyuus for Al and Ed are going to reprise their roles.
Meh..well that sucks. I dunno. I just think Romi Paku's annoying and overrated. |
Whoa, how big of a difference was the Anime series from the Manga? :3
|
Romi Paku was perfect for the role. Al's voice, on the other hand, grates on me horribly. TEH RIE notwithstanding.
|
Quote:
@bigblah - I dont hate her that much. I did like her as Ed and Nana. |
Watched this a few times yesterday. Pretty good start, I think. Obvious filler and ridiculously fast-paced story to introduce non-veterans to the story.
The thing that pissed me off the most was the amount of foreshadowing they threw in, even in the OP, just to satisfy the manga readers—kind of like "HEY GUYS, JUST IN CASE YOU DIDNT KNOW, THIS IS THE MANGA STORYLINE!" Totally unnecessary. It also worries me to think about how much of the beginning they're going to gloss over just to get to the good stuff. Even at 2 chapters an episode (which is pretty standard), it'll be a tight fit to finish up the series, which should end anywhere from chapter 100-110. I'd like it much more if they took two years and made a good 102 episode series that really does the manga thorough justice. |
I haven't downloaded the first episode yet, but it sounds like a good thing if they're speeding through the beginning. The manga and original anime didn't really diverge on any major points until around episode 30, so I'd rather we just hurry up and get to the new stuff. The other series isn't that old and people can just watch that for a slower, more detailed start.
|
The show had a poo ending and the follow-up movie was pretty underwhelming. Hopefully this show will not be poo.
|
Just watched the first episode myself. What's wrong with glossing over the beginning that most people have already seen? It's so popular in Japan surely most folks have at least a passing knowledge of the setup (how the boys lost their bodies and their objectives to get them back), so there's no point in belaboring things. Honestly, I don't care all that much for the stuff that happens before a certain death, and I certainly don't want to go through the whole Lior bit again. The first ep. gives some nice foreshadowing for those who already know what's coming, while at the same time delivering new material to keep things fresh. #2 looks to be a flashback to their childhood, so maybe they'll just skip Lior entirely (keep in mind I know nothing about plans for the series except watching the actual show, so if there are articles detailing plot plans, I haven't read them).
Also, the ED animation is the best ever. I wish there were shots without the credits so I could make an av/sig. |
I just finished watching the first episode, and so far I like how things are being done. I've kept up with the manga and rewatched the first series so many times that I really didn't want to sit through several episodes of introductions. The Ice Alchemist fight was a nice way to get things going and set up a lot of the major characters while showing something new. It was kind of strange to have everyone know the boys except for Hughes, but I'm all for some small changes to keep things interesting.
Did anyone else's subs keep calling Bradley the "Fuhrer President?" Eclipse did that, and it sounds incredibly awkward. |
This is why you use the gSS [gg + BSS] subs instead. :tpg:
We really don't need eight scrub groups doing it when gSS and Shinsen are already on the case and doing a much better job. |
Wow, that was horrible. How many times in the first 6 minutes did they refer to Edward's height? And how many times before did that stop being funny?
It was quite fast and effective in narrative, though. This one episode spanned a story that would've taken most anime series an entire season to complete. I quite liked the original series, even with its oscillating quality at the end. (Never saw the movie.) |
How many fricken groups do we need subbing FMA 2...seriously there are like 7 now....
|
Quote:
Overall a decent episode to serve as a starting point by introducing most of the major players while throwing in a decent amount of action that'll be a taste of things to come. |
It's a regular joke even in the manga, so it didn't really bother me. Looked to me like they just did a extra starting episode before moving to the manga story next ep~. Overally I think the first series had a bit sharper/tougher feel to it, but I wouldn't mind if they skip the dog & loli part for example ;_;
|
Quote:
|
I enjoyed it...not so keen on the opening and ending songs though...
I've never read the manga, and enjoyed the first series immensely...I wonder how long before the series really moves away from the plot of the first series, it worries me that I'll become bored before the divergence occurs. I would also like to say that 'crayons' are underrated in animation... |
A friend of mine tried watching the other FMA series 2 months ago. Sayin' he didn't like it because it didn't have too much action and was waitng for "more than" 10 episodes to see a fight but it just wasn't enough. In this one, there was story and lots of action. So he chose this road ;p.
|
Nice! Looks great so far!
Been checking out Shinsen-Subs' work but it looks like they're stuck in a rut now. They got a letter from FUNimation asking them to stop, which the group basically said "kiss my ass" to. But now their translator has taken off.... Shinsen-Subs :: News & Updates Not looking good. Anyone recommend another group's subs? I might have to go with Tails' suggestion and look out for gss instead though. I didn't see the original anime series since I was still into the manga, and later hearing that it went out on a different tangent made me miss it altogether. I'm looking forward to seeing Ling, RanFan and old man Fuu make their appearences. Was Maria Ross ever in the first TV series? :eye: |
I was wondering why Shinsen hadn't done ep. 4. Still, they insisted on releasing in mkv, which I can't convert over to my iPod, so I had to wait for some other group to hard-sub it. I've got ep. 4 from Eclipse in my queue to watch, but I've got to see ep. 3 first.
Yes, Maria Ross was in the first series, but she plays a larger role in the manga. |
Man you guys are slow. Anyway GSS dropped FMA in favor of picking up Sengoku Basara (FUCK YEAH PUT YA SUBS ON), and since Shinsen isn't based in America they're just releasing under the group name The Alchemists now. They had episode 4 up at the same time they always do on Sunday.
|
Does anyone know why Tokyotosho has been broken for weeks? There's no notice or anything; just a blank page.
I'm downloading ep. 4 right now, and so far I've been pleased with how the new series is going. I thought it was odd how it skipped over Tucker since he was one of the only major differences between the early episodes and the manga, but this episode will fix that. |
Site says:
Quote:
|
Quote:
And yeah, I googled tokyotosho the other day and found the message Tails posted. The .info works just fine. |
Quote:
|
Am I the only one here who's a tad discontented with how this series is turning out? Everything just seems so fast-paced that you haven't had time to properly digest the material and all of the strong drama associated with this before they move on to the next story arc. I'm really hoping that this is just a phase to get to the diverging point, but from the standpoint of writing a good story, this breakneck speed is just terrible.
If my reliable sources didn't tell me to be patient, I'd be tempted to declare that the manga enthusiasts are deluded in their thinking at this point. |
Again, the original series never really diverged from the manga until around the 30's (Rush Valley and Sensei's arrival), so the rushed speed is necessary to get to the different stuff. If it slowed down then we'd just be watching the same things all over again. It's making time for divergences like Shou Tucker, so I'm not overly concerned.
|
I'm actually pretty pleased with the pacing of the new series. First-time viewers like Tails seem to enjoy it too so they're doing something right.
|
Whoa, episode 8 and 9 already has the 5th Laboratory bit done with...
I really like the pacing here, hope it keeps up until wherever it was that the first anime series started diverging from the manga. Then it better slow down and focus more on the story. :D Did any one else notice when Winry arrived at Central in episode 9.... Spoiler:
With the preview to episode 10, we're coming to the source of Mustang's pain.... Spoiler:
|
Well, episode 11 deals with the auto-mail girl in Rush Valley according to the preview, so we'll be going into the new stuff in either 11 or 12. I can't remember if the Xing folks show up during or after that chase.
Ep. 10:
|
Man, I don't know if this a good thing or not, showing events in a slightly different way... but the battle between Ed and Greed wasn't how I remember it from the manga.
Spoiler:
I know they're trying to get to the new bits for the manga, but this is getting weird. |
Quote:
I can't really say I know what they're thinking. A lot of it is unimportant now, but they're breaking ties that become relevant later in the series. Spoiler:
edit// And it seems like they kinda fucked up 15 too. At least the new OP and ED sequences are neato. Spoiler:
|
Heads up for all you folks watching, the 12th IAAF World Championships in Athletics will be airing this week, so episode 21 of FMA:B will be delayed until August 30th.
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:28 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.