Quote:
Originally Posted by niki
(Post 517087)
Seriously, I realize Horde is purely satirical, but did you honestly gave stuff like Arvinger or Antestor a chance ?
|
No, and I never will. Call me narrow-minded if you want, but I'm not going to waste time on worthless contradictory garbage when there is so much other good music out there to seek.
Quote:
And bleh, how are Moonsorrow live btw ? I really can't imagine.
|
They are amazing, though I would have preferred if they
hadn't played that long song (I think most of it is filler). The rest was awesome though.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DarkLink2135
(Post 517091)
I don't limit my black metal choices just based on lyrical content. Having an entire genre of music being limited upon the lyrical content is just silly anyway. Music is defined by the sound, and when I can barely make out what the hell they are saying anyway, it makes little difference to me whether they are praising Satan or God.
|
Oh boy... Where to begin.
Music isn't just a bunch of sound waves. Music is an art form, and as such, an expression of human ideas. A song can have an atmosphere, moods, feelings, and thoughts, and this can happen *gasp* even
without lyrics! Similar-styled songs by similar-styled bands form a genre. One of those genre, black metal, is represented by its raw, primitive, hateful, gritty, christian-hating feel. Therefore, it makes absolutely
no sense to have black metal singing about Jesus and christianity (or Judaism for that matter, I should have said "Abraham-religion-hating feel" but it sounded more awkward :P). If you don't care about the meaning behind the music and just like to hear pleasant sound waves, fine, go ahead, but don't start saying it's silly that a genre is "silly that a genre is limited upon the lyrical content", because that's misleading and inaccurate, not to mention false. Black metal isn't limited to anti-christianity: it can be about satanism and anti-christianity, yes, but also about rebellion, individuality and rejection of modern PCness, war, violence, paganism, mythology, history, nihilism, and even more unpleasant subjects like racism and national socialism. Those things are not incompatible per se. But preaching of christianity is simply not compatible, and neither is singing about love or flowers (doesn't a "black metal love song" strike you as genuinely ridiculous? well, it should, and the same :rolleyes: should occur if you encounter "christian 'black' metal"). I would say the same thing about death metal: a death metal love song is just as stupid as "christian death metal". Note that I'm not talking about having elements from christian mythology (e.g. Dante's Inferno by Iced Earth isn't "christian metal"), but specifically about
pro-christian themes and worse, preaching.
Music isn't created in a void. Those thoughts that drive an artist to create his work are what fuels him and his creation, whether there are lyrics or not. You can't just separate the two because they are intrisically linked. Most genres of music don't have specific thematics (or if you prefer, "restrictions", though I find this needlessly pejorative and misleading), but some do, with varying ranges: gospel music, black metal, straight edge punk, folk music (to a certain extent, in some subgenres at least), to name a few.
Never thought I'd have to write so much about a genre I don't really care that much for (I only like a handful of black metal bands)... but I see the "it's just sound!" argument so much it's starting to itch. ;)