| Kaleb.G |
Nov 6, 2006 02:29 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by AWACS Eagle Eye
I don't think we've had any rule like that before, but it might've been discussed at some point. I remember a while back David Deluxe wanted to nominate Zero from the Ace Combat Zero game rip, but Kaleb put a hold on it until the soundtrack came out in order to gauge popularity, so maybe you were thinking about that too.
|
Correct. Well, that and the fact that there was no need to use the game rip version when the OST would be coming out so soon. The OST version is easier to keep tabs on, because it's official.
Quote:
Originally Posted by orion_mk3
Seems like a waiting period would be a good rule of thumb in many cases, if not an "official" rule. After all, look what happened to Zero in the BSC--it was in the top 16.
|
Yeah, I agree. It's hard to judge a piece of music as being obscure when it just came out.
Look at Katamari Damacy for a perfect example. The OST came out in May 2004 and wasn't that big, but by October (after the U.S. release of the game) everyone had heard of it. Of course, in that case, the popularity of the music hinged on the game itself.
Regardless, a waiting period sounds like a good idea to me. |
