The Case of the Serrated Scalpel~

Correct.

Draconis: 12
Elixir: 11
Qwarky: 6
Skills: 5
CHz: 3
Solis: 2
TheKnightOfNee: 2
Iwata: 2
StarmanDX: 2
kuttlas: 2
Leknaat: 1
Dekoa: 1
Philia: 1
AcerBandit: 1
Syndrome: 1
randomwab: 1
^-^: 1
Infernal Monkey: 1
Happy Cow: 1

Holy crap.

Unison?

Beat me to it :s! Unison was an absolutely terrible game XP.

Chaotic's correct.

Unison looks like an ultra beta version of idolm@ster ;_;

Scores
Draconis: 12
Elixir: 11
Qwarky: 6
Skills: 5
CHz: 3
Solis: 2
TheKnightOfNee: 2
Iwata: 2
StarmanDX: 2
kuttlas: 2
Leknaat: 1
Dekoa: 1
Philia: 1
AcerBandit: 1
Syndrome: 1
randomwab: 1
^-^: 1
Infernal Monkey: 1
Happy Cow: 1
Chaotic: 1

Yay, I finally scored once!

http://img443.imageshack.us/img443/4819/asdasdke3.jpg

that's obscure ^^

dammit, here I went to find the name of the game, knowing what it is but it's on the tip of my tongue...and Inhert's post threw me for a loop till I found the game :( He wins

Yep. Thought I should just post on what I thought most of these games were... :| I'm at least happy I scored once. But curses that it had to be a music game...

Scores
Draconis: 12
Elixir: 11
Qwarky: 6
Skills: 5
CHz: 3
Solis: 2
TheKnightOfNee: 2
Iwata: 2
StarmanDX: 2
kuttlas: 2
Leknaat: 1
Dekoa: 1
Philia: 1
AcerBandit: 1
Syndrome: 1
randomwab: 1
^-^: 1
Infernal Monkey: 1
Happy Cow: 1
Chaotic: 1
Inhert: 1

^^

http://content.imagesocket.com/images/03d9c.jpg

That's Nox, right?

yep ^^

Hooray!

Try this for size then

http://staff.gamingforce.com/qwarky/7025.jpg

Hmm, that one I had to think about...my gut reaction was something else, but I realized it couldn't be that when I saw that the person was riding in the back of a vehicle and the game in the screenshot doesn't have a UI.

So the only other FPS type game that fits that look which I can recall is...Dead Man's Hand?

Nope, it's not a western. I think you can set a UI visible from the options, so whatever else you thought might not be out of the question.

Console or PC? Maybe hinting a release date or developer would help here.

Both, actually. Came out on the Xbox first, though.

Hint: It doesn't focus around gunplay.

Clive Barker's Undying?

Ooh close, but not quite. Think newer. Plus Undying was PC only.

Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth

That's the one, good job.

Scores
Draconis: 12
Elixir: 11
Qwarky: 7
Skills: 5
CHz: 3
Solis: 2
randomwab: 2
TheKnightOfNee: 2
Iwata: 2
StarmanDX: 2
kuttlas: 2
Leknaat: 1
Dekoa: 1
Philia: 1
AcerBandit: 1
Syndrome: 1
^-^: 1
Infernal Monkey: 1
Happy Cow: 1
Chaotic: 1
Inhert: 1

Awesome, try this one.

http://img405.imageshack.us/img405/6209/winot9.jpg

That's Bishi Bashi 2, is it not?

More Bishi Bashi?

EDIT:
lawl beaten